Pilgrim State Hospital           

ticket-excursion_lirr-hospitals_RichardMakse.jpg (48723 bytes)
 A "special excursion" ticket for the three (3) State Hospitals and not a regular issue.  Normal fares for the train to Pilgrim State Hospital station were issued as "Brentwood" printed ticket stock. Archive: Richard Makse

G5s-23-Hospital Train First Run E at Sta-Pilgrim State-Brentwood-View NW-06-24-34 (Keller).jpg (104295 bytes)
Looking northwest, G5s #23 is shown here pulling the first run of hospital train #4228 eastbound into the new Pilgrim State Hospital station at Brentwood, NY on June 24, 1934.  The return trip west became train #4225.  Over the years, the numbers of the hospital trains have changed.  Note that this train is indicated on the Emery map following.  (Dave Keller
 and Art Huneke data, Dave Keller archive)

Pilgrim State Hospital:  Spur off Main Line constructed in 1930 for coal delivery to the institution.  Per ETT #1, effective 6/24/34, station with covered shelter in service, and first passenger train to hospital scheduled.  Discontinued as station stop effective 5/21/78.  Spur truncated: 19__?  and tracks removed from upper portion of spur.  Lower portion of spur left intact and used by LIRR as storage track.  As of 2013, covered shelter and platform still in place but heavily overgrown.  (Dave Keller's "Long Island Rail Road Station History" listing)

ETT No. 2-Eff. 05-20-74-Pilgrim State Hospital Service (Keller) (Red-Lined).jpg (547266 bytes)Here are the eastbound and westbound train listings for service to Pilgrim State Hospital as they appeared in LIRR Employee Timetable #2, effective 5/20/74.  The yellow pages indicate Saturdays and Sundays only, with additional notes indicating the hospital trains run Sundays only.

The eastbound train, #4228, makes a morning stop at Pinelawn to drop off visitors to the cemetery and a note in the column states that it arrives at Pilgrim switch at 10:55 am, and at the hospital at 11:10.  The note continues to state that the train leaves the hospital at 12:20 pm, running light to the timetable-listed Pilgrim switch at 12:40 pm, then continuing to run light, passing SG cabin at 12:45, Central Islip at 12:50 and reaching Ronkonkoma at 12:57 pm where the engine will be run around the train and then laid up for the return trip.  If a push-pull train, then there will be no need to run the engine around the train, but it will lay up in the yard nonetheless.

The westbound train, #4253, leaves at 2:15 pm from Ronkonkoma where it's been laying up since arriving there at 12:57 pm.  It runs light westbound passing Central Islip at 2:22 pm and SG cabin at 2:27 pm.  Notes in the column indicate arrival at Pilgrim switch at 2:34 pm.   It doesn't give an arrival time at the hospital but states that it leaves the station there at 3:05 pm.  The timetable listing shows the westbound run arriving at Pilgrim switch at 3:16 pm then heading to Jamaica, making an afternoon return stop at Pinelawn to pick up visitors returning from the cemetery.  (You'll notice that most of the morning and afternoon trains make a Pinelawn station stop for cemetery visitors.)


Note that while the eastbound train was numbered #4228 in 1974, it had changed to #4236 by the last day of service on May 21, 1978. 
 The westbound train number, however, remained the same.  (Dave Keller data and archive)

emery-map_MP38-39_5-58.jpg (196291 bytes)
Map of MP 38 to MP 39 showing the Edgewood State Hospital spur/siding at the left, the former Edgewood station site in the center and the Pilgrim State Hospital spur/siding at the right, effective May, 1958.  The Pilgrim State Hospital spur/siding is continued on the next map at the right, showing the power plant, related sidings and station location.  (Robert Emery map, Dave Keller archive)
emery-map-Pilgrim-State-spur_5-58.jpg (76475 bytes)
Emery map Pilgrim State Spur - 5/1958
Archive: Dave Keller
Brentwood67.jpg (84835 bytes)
LIRR 1966 map Brentwood/Pilgrim State spur

Station-Pilgrim-State-Hospital_1-29-46_(Weber-Morrison-Keller).jpg (77154 bytes)
Pilgrim State Hospital Station 1/29/1946 view E (F. W. Weber photo, Dave Keller archive and data) Compare this view with the earlier view of the first train to arrive in 1934 (photo, top right). Note that by this time, the bumper that had been installed at the very end of the station platform has been removed, and the track extended further east into the dirt hill beyond, to allow the locomotive to clear the station platform and allow space at the short concrete platform for an additional passenger car to be spotted there. Also note that the concrete platform only extends to the edge of the covered shelter. In later years, an asphalt extension to the concrete platform was added on the west end. (Dave Keller data)

Station-Pilgrim State Hospital - View W - 01-29-46 (Weber-Keller).jpg (117747 bytes)
Pilgrim State Hospital Station 1/29/1946 view W (F. W. Weber photo, Dave Keller archive and data)
Station-Pilgrim State Hospital-Cinder Platform - View W - 01-29-46 (Weber-Keller).jpg (114556 bytes)
Pilgrim State Hospital Cinder Platform View W 1/29/1946 (F. W. Weber photo, Dave Keller archive and data)
C420-210-Pilgrim State Hospital Station-Brentwood-12-28-75 (Madden-Keller).jpg (83952 bytes)
C420 #210 Pilgrim State Hospital Station Brentwood 12/28/1975 (Madden-Keller)
C420-226-Train-Pilgrim-State-Hospital Station-Brentwood-03-76_Keller.jpg (149468 bytes)
C420 #226 Pilgrim State Hospital Station Brentwood 
3/1976 Archive: Dave Keller
C420-222-Train-Pilgrim State Hospital Station-Brentwood-10-77 (Huneke-Keller).jpg (81477 bytes)
C420 #222 Pilgrim State Hospital Station Brentwood 
10/1977 Photo: Art Huneke  Archive: Dave Keller
FA2-605-Train-Pilgrim State Hospital Station-Brentwood-07-77 (Keller).jpg (75367 bytes)
FA2 #605 Pilgrim State Hospital Station Brentwood
7/1977 Archive: Dave Keller
Train-4244_entering- Pilgrim-State-Hospital_9-01-1968_makse.jpg (53372 bytes)
Train #4244 entering Pilgrim State Hospital 9/01/68
Train-4244_clearing-main_Pilgrim_9-01-1968_makse.jpg (50528 bytes)
Train #4244 clearing Pilgrim State Hospital 9/01/68
On September 1, 1968, I took the Sunday only train #4244 from Jamaica to Pilgrim State Hospital, recording its events between PILGRIM (the main track switch, designated as a station) and the hospital station. 

In this view, the head end man stands at the switch waiting to normal it while the rear end man pulls two on the communicating whistle to stop the train clear of the main. Barely visible at the right is conductor at the T box, ready to report the train #4244 clear of the main at Pilgrim.

Note that signal 388, shunted by the open switch, is improperly displaying a Permissive-Block instead of a Caution aspect--the lower marker light is burned out. 388 was the distant signal to SG block station but also served as a distant switch indicator. Info/photos: Richard Makse

The Last Passenger Train Service to Pilgrim State Hospital

The last passenger train service to Pilgrim State Hospital in Brentwood, NY was on May 21, 1978.  It consisted of eastbound, Sunday-only train #4236 and westbound Sunday-only train #4253.

Until recent years when the LIRR renumbered many trains, #200-series trains were Ronkonkoma / Main Line trains (i.e. #204/#211 were the eastbound and westbound daily run to Greenport and back).  The number "4" preceding the train number designated the train as a Saturday / Sunday / Holiday (or all three) train. The Pinelawn Cemetery trains were Saturday-Sunday trains but the Pilgrim State Hospital train was Sunday-only, making the additional stop at Pinelawn in each direction.

There was no means to turn the train at Pilgrim nor was there a run-around track, so the train would nose into the platform, unload the passengers, then, running light, back out onto the Main in a westbound direction, clear Pilgrim switch, reverse direction and head east to Ronkonkoma where the train entered the yard, the locomotive would be cut off, run around the train either via the wye or a siding track and coupled onto the west end.

When it was time to head back west in the afternoon to pick up the returning riders who visited patients at the hospital, the train would again clear the Pilgrim switch, reverse direction, back eastbound into the spur up to the station, load the passengers, then head west.

They got smart when they began to use push-pull service there, because it eliminated that need to turn the train.  There was NOTHING at Pilgrim station or at nearby Pine Aire at the time, that could occupy hours of layover.  (Dave Keller data)


LIRR Employee timetable #4, eff. May, 1977 NO longer shows the light runs to and from Ronkonkoma.  With the use of push-pull trains to the hospital, the need to run the train out to Ronkonkoma to turn the engine or run it around the train and lay up until the return trip was no longer necessary.  I gather the LIRR deemed it more cost-effective to let the train layup either at the hospital platform or on the Pine Aire siding, north of the Main, until departure time.  (Jeff Erlitz archive, Dave Keller data)

FA2-607-WB Ronk Train passing FA1-618-PSH Train on Hospital Spur-Pine Aire-12-28-75 (Madden-Keller).jpg (104515 bytes)
In this view looking NE, ALCO FA2 #607 leads westbound push-pull train from Ronkonkoma past ALCO FA1 #618 with westbound Pilgrim State Hospital push-pull train on hospital spur west of Pine-Aire, NY on December 28, 1975. The remains of an early snowfall are still visible on the cold ground.   (Madden-Keller)
MP15ac-154-GP38-2-276-Train 4236-Last Eastbound to Pilgrim State Hospital-Pine Aire Siding-View NE-05-21-78 (Madden-Keller).jpg (138997 bytes)
MP15ac #154 GP38-2 #276 Train #4236 Last eastbound to Pilgrim State Hospital - Pine Aire Siding  view NE 05/21/1978 (Madden-Keller)

MP15ac-154-GP38-2-276-Train 4253-Last Westbound from Pilgrim State Hospital-on Spur-View SE-05-21-78 (Madden-Keller).jpg (140426 bytes)
MP15ac #154 and GP38-2 #276 Train #4253 LAST RUN westbound 
from Pilgrim State Hospital on Spur view SE 5/21/78 (Madden-Keller)

MP15ac-154_ GP38-2-276_Train-4253_westbound_Last Day Psgr Svc to Pilgrim State Hospital_At Jct_FA1-616, Train 4203 WB_ Pine-Aire_ 05-21-78_Madden-Keller.jpg (114773 bytes)
MP15ac #154 and GP38-2 #276  Last day passenger service Train #4253 westbound 
 to Pilgrim State Hospital at junction with FA1 #616 Train #4203 
westbound at Pine Aire 5/21/1978 (Madden-Keller)

Pilgrim-State-Hospital-Train_Last-Run_05-21-1978.jpg (241661 bytes)
"Train to Pilgrim State Makes Its Last Run" 
Newsday May 22, 1978 Page 16 by Steve Wick

GP38-2-276_MP15ac -154_Train - Last Day Psgr Svc to Pilgrim State Hospital  - Pine Aire - 05-21-78 (Madden-Keller).jpg (138530 bytes)
GP38-2 #276 and MP15ac #154 Last day Train #4253 passenger service to 
Pilgrim State Hospital Pine Aire 5/21/1978 (Madden-Keller)
MP15ac -154_GP38-2-276_Train 4253 WB- Last Day Psgr Svc to Pilgrim State Hospital  - Pine Aire - 05-21-78 (Madden-Keller).jpg (136007 bytes)
MP15ac #154 and GP38-2 #276 Last day Train #4253 passenger service to 
Pilgrim State Hospital Pine Aire 5/21/1978 (Madden-Keller)

Here's the procedure used on the runs up the spur in the last years as well as on the last day of passenger service:

The hospital train eastbound, #4236, would head onto the spur and into the station with the locomotive(s) on the east end.  After the passengers had left, the train was backed westbound out onto the Main Line, a reverse move made, and then headed eastbound to Ronkonkoma where the locomotive(s) was (were) run around the train on the wye and all laid up in the yard for the return trip to the hospital as westbound train #4253.  At the junction, the train was BACKED into the hospital spur in preparation for the scheduled westbound return train with the locomotive(s) on the west end.  Why there were TWO locomotives on this last run is a mystery, unless one of the engines was giving trouble or was expected to possibly give trouble and the LIRR was playing it safe. Info: Dave Keller 

Pilgrim State Hospital - March 25, 2006
Photos: Pat Masterson

emery-map-pine-aire-Masterson-photo-locations.jpg (191263 bytes)
Pine Aire - Pilgrim State Spur photo locations

emery-map-Pilgrim-State-spur_masterson-photo-locations.jpg (81416 bytes)
Pilgrim State Hospital Spur photo locations

Pine-Aire-siding_viewW_LIRR-doubletracked- electrified-Main-Line-left_Pat-Masterson.jpg (261336 bytes)
1. Pilgrim Switch showing the double-tracked, electrified Main Line at the left, the Pine Aire siding in the center foreground and the hospital spur in the right foreground.

Pilgrim Spur-Track Car-Pine Aire Siding-Elec Sub-Station-View E-03-25-06 (Masterson-Keller).jpg (93587 bytes)
2. The southern portion of the Pilgrim Spur was left intact and used for storage.  In this view taken on March 25, 2006 looking east towards the Sagtikos Parkway overpass, track cars are laying up on the spur.  The Pine Aire siding is to the right of the MOW track cars, the double tracked, electrified Main Line is at the far right and the LIRR electric substation is visible in the right background. (Pat Masterson photo, Dave Keller archive and data)
"Getting back on the Track"
How do you rerail a 200 ton Alco diesel locomotive? Answer: Slowly and carefully. The LIRR's wreck train and crew, under wreckmaster Jimmy Van Time, worked through Sunday night, January 24 and Monday morning to rerail a seven car train after it was derailed by an open switch.

In addition to LIRR personnel, a small army of firemen from neighboring communities responded to the emergency remaining through the night until all passengers and injured had been removed from the wreckage. 

There was one fatality: ticket collector Donald J. Wheeler of North Babylon. LIRR police joined with Suffolk County authorities to pinpoint the cause of the derailment. Verdict: Unknown youths deliberately reversed the switch which caused the train to leave the tracks at the Pilgrim State Hospital spur. 

Pilgrim_sabotoge_Castelli.jpg (157314 bytes)
"Sabotage causes young trainman's death" 01/24/1971 Collection: Al Castelli

Long-Island_METRO-LINES_page7_Getting-Back-on-Track_Huneke-Castelli.jpg (88795 bytes)
Long Island METRO LINES page 7 Photos: Art Huneke Collection: Al Castelli

Referring to Emery's map, you'll note the location of the Pilgrim switch and the hospital spur leading directly off the single-tracked Main Line. As a result of a deadly, vandal-related derailment that occurred at this location on January 24, 1971, the old, stone, overgrade crossing of the former private road just to the west of here was solidly filled in and Pine Aire siding was installed.  Access to the Pilgrim switch was moved from its former, direct, Main Line location to a point along the new siding, to prevent this sort of tragedy from happening again.  (Dave Keller data)

pilgrim_ROW_3-25-06_Pat-Masterson.jpg (311735 bytes)
3. Pilgrim State Hospital ROW
pilgrim_power-house_viewN_Pat-Masterson.jpg (197823 bytes)
4. Pilgrim State Hospital powerhouse -  view N

pilgrim_power-house_coal-trestle_viewW_Pat-Masterson.jpg (265573 bytes)
5. Pilgrim State Hospital powerhouse coal trestle - view W

coal-trestle_track-viewE_Pat-Masterson.jpg (264456 bytes)
6. Pilgrim State Hospital coal trestle track level - view E

pilgrim_coal-trestle_viewSW_Pat-Masterson.jpg (218967 bytes)
7. Pilgrim State Hospital power house coal trestle -  view SW
Pilgrim-station-shed_viewE_Pat-Masterson.jpg (373824 bytes)
8. Pilgrim State Hospital station shed - view E
pilgrim_station-shed_viewS-G-Road_Pat-Masterson.jpg (259045 bytes)
9. Pilgrim State Hospital station shed - view S from G Road
end-of-track_viewW_Pat-Masterson.jpg (377960 bytes)
10. Pilgrim State Hospital spur end-of-track - view W
MP15ac-159 (NY&A) and Freight-Pilgrim Spur-View NE-11-17-99 (Keller).jpg (125174 bytes)
Former LIRR and now New York & Atlantic Railway MP15ac #159 is pulling a string of freight cars westbound off the old Pilgrim State Hospital spur west of Pine Aire in this image from November 17, 1999. While the last passenger train was run on this spur in 1978, coal trains ceased when the hospital's power plant shut down and the station area became completely overgrown in the years following, the lower portion of the spur remained in use to store equipment such as track cars during track work as well as freight cars. The NY&A took over LIRR freight operations on May 11, 1997 with a 20-year lease.  MP15ac #159 is shown here removing some stored freight cars from the spur to head back west.  This view is northeast.  (David Keller data and archive)